Risks of Refusing Medical Treatment During an Injury Claim
By Mason ArnaoPublished
By Mason ArnaoReviewed by Mason Arnao
It can. You keep the right to say no to treatment, but the risks of refusing medical treatment during a claim are real: depending on the kind of claim, turning down or stopping recommended care can reduce what you recover, pause your payments, or cost you benefits entirely. As a patient, you have the right to make informed decisions and to request or refuse treatment, and filing a claim doesn’t take that right away.
What changes is how the people deciding your claim may treat that choice. Social Security, for example, says that if you don’t follow prescribed treatment expected to restore your ability to work and you don’t have a good reason, it will not find you disabled or will stop your benefits. In a California personal injury case, jurors are instructed that a plaintiff can’t recover damages the defendant proves could have been avoided with reasonable effort or expense. And in the federal workers’ compensation program for federal employees, refusing a medical exam the program directs suspends your compensation.
This guide covers each of those situations: your rights as a patient, how refusing care can come up in a personal injury claim, Social Security’s treatment rule for SSDI and SSI, what happens if you skip a required exam in workers’ comp, the reasons these rules accept and how to document yours, and what to do when your concern is really about the care being offered.
The short answer: you can say no, but your claim may pay less
Yes, you can refuse medical treatment. But if you have an injury claim, a disability application, or a workers’ compensation case open, refusing care can lower what you receive or stop your benefits entirely. Your right to decide about your own body and the rules of your claim are separate questions.
Here is how the main systems treat a refusal:
- As a hospital patient: Hospitals must respect your federal right to make informed decisions and to request or refuse treatment.
- In a personal injury lawsuit: The person you are suing may argue that you should not be paid for harm you could have reasonably avoided. California’s jury instructions, for example, say a plaintiff can’t recover damages the defendant proves were avoidable with reasonable effort or expense.
- In SSDI and SSI: If your doctor prescribes treatment that is expected to restore your ability to work and you don’t follow it without a good reason, Social Security will not find you disabled, or will stop your benefits. Social Security’s guidance on what counts as good cause lists reasons it accepts.
- In federal workers’ compensation: If you are a federal employee and you refuse or obstruct an exam ordered by the Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs, your compensation can be suspended.
A refusal does not automatically end a claim. In each system, the reason you said no can matter a great deal. The sections below explain each system in turn, the reasons the rules accept, and how to document your reason so it is on record if anyone questions it later.
Your right to refuse treatment as a patient
You have a recognized right to say no to medical treatment. For hospital care, that right appears in federal patient-rights rules for hospitals (42 CFR 482.13). Under these rules, a hospital must protect your rights as a patient. Whenever possible, it must also tell you what those rights are before it gives you care or stops it.
What the patient-rights rules cover
The rules give you, or your representative, the right to:
- Be told about your health status so you understand what is going on with your body.
- Take part in planning your care, including the decisions that shape your treatment.
- Request or refuse treatment after you have the information you need to make an informed choice.
Together, these rights mean a hospital cannot simply treat you without involving you. If a doctor recommends surgery, a procedure, or a medication, you can ask questions, take time to think, and decline.
Where the right stops
The right to refuse has limits. The same rule says it is not a way to demand treatment or services that are medically unnecessary or inappropriate. You can turn down care, but you cannot require a hospital to give you care that your providers decide you don’t need.
Why this matters for your claim
These rights protect your choices as a patient, but they don’t protect your claim. A personal injury case, a Social Security disability application, and a workers’ compensation claim each follow their own rules. Those rules can treat a refusal very differently from how a hospital does. Saying no to care can still affect what you are paid or whether benefits continue. The sections below explain how each type of claim handles a refusal.
Personal injury claims: refusing care and the failure-to-mitigate defense
If you turn down reasonable treatment after an accident, the person or company you’re suing can argue that some of your harm was avoidable. Lawyers call this the “failure to mitigate damages” defense. If it works, it can reduce what you recover. It does not wipe out your claim.
California’s official civil jury instructions show how this defense works in one state. Under California’s jury instruction on mitigation of damages in personal injury cases (CACI No. 3930), an injured person can’t recover damages for harm the defendant proves could have been avoided with reasonable effort or expense.
What this means for you, using the California example
- The defendant has to prove it. You don’t have to show you did everything right. The other side carries the burden of proving that you failed to mitigate.
- Only the avoidable part is cut. Any reduction applies just to the harm that reasonable effort or expense would have prevented. The defendant still pays for harm that would have happened anyway.
- “Reasonable” is the test. The question is whether avoiding the harm would have taken reasonable effort or expense. It is not whether you followed every possible recommendation.
Here’s how that could look in practice. Suppose a jury finds that skipping a recommended course of care made part of your injury worse. That added portion may be cut. The harm caused by the accident itself still counts toward your damages.
Your state may be different. CACI No. 3930 is a California instruction. Other states set their own rules on mitigation, so check the law where your claim is filed. If you’re still getting oriented, it can also help to understand how a personal injury claim works, from proof to deadlines. That way you can see where questions about your medical care might come up.

SSDI and SSI: the rule on following prescribed treatment
Yes, refusing treatment can cost you disability benefits, but only in specific situations. Under the federal regulation on this issue, 20 CFR 404.1530, you must follow treatment your medical source prescribed if that treatment is expected to restore your ability to work. If you don’t follow it and don’t have a good reason, Social Security will not find you disabled. If you already receive benefits, it will stop them.
What SSA considers before deciding
SSA does not treat every refusal the same way. When it decides whether your reason is acceptable, the regulation says it weighs:
- Your physical limitations
- Your mental limitations
- Your educational limitations
- Your language limitations
The regulation also gives examples of acceptable reasons. One is declining a surgery that was already tried once and failed. Another is declining an amputation.
How SSR 18-3p fits in
Social Security’s ruling SSR 18-3p covers both SSDI (Title II) and SSI (Title XVI). It explains how SSA reaches these decisions and what counts as good cause. Its examples include:
- Religious beliefs that conflict with the treatment
- Disagreement among your own medical sources about whether the treatment is right for you
The ruling also addresses who has to show good cause. In practice, that means your reason should be clear in your records and in what you tell SSA. A refusal with no explanation leaves SSA little to weigh in your favor.
If your claim is already headed to a judge, a failure-to-follow-treatment question can come up at the hearing. Our guide to preparing for an SSDI hearing before a judge walks through how to get ready to explain your treatment history in your own words.

Workers’ comp: skipping a required medical exam
If you are a federal employee with a workers’ comp claim, refusing an exam that the program orders can stop your payments. Federal workers are covered by the Federal Employees’ Compensation Act (FECA), which is run by the Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs (OWCP). Under the federal rule on failing to report for or obstructing an OWCP-directed exam, refusing to attend or obstructing a second opinion or referee examination suspends your right to compensation until the refusal stops.
What happens under FECA if you refuse or obstruct an exam
- Compensation is suspended. Payments stop while the refusal or obstruction continues.
- You lose pay for the refusal period. You forfeit compensation for the time you were refusing. Any money already paid to you for that time is treated as an overpayment, which means you may have to pay it back.
- You have 14 days to explain. If you miss an exam, you can give OWCP your reason within 14 days. If OWCP decides the reason is not good cause, your compensation is suspended.
- Payments can restart. Compensation resumes from the date you agree to attend the exam. It does not go back to cover the refusal period.
If something keeps you from attending, such as a hospital stay, a conflicting medical appointment or a transportation problem, tell OWCP right away. Keep a copy of what you send, along with any records that back up your reason. The 14-day window is short, so do not wait for a letter before you respond.
State workers’ comp is different
FECA applies only to federal employees. Most workers are covered by their state’s workers’ comp system, and each state sets its own rules for exams, including who chooses the doctor, how much notice you get and what happens if you miss one. If your claim is in Florida, our guide explains what to expect at a Florida workers’ comp IME. In any other state, check the notice your employer or insurer sent you. It should name the exam and say who to contact if you cannot make it.
Reasons the rules accept, and how to document yours
Having a real reason to decline or delay care does not automatically protect your claim. It helps most when the reason is written down before anyone asks for it.
Reasons Social Security has recognized
- Repeat of a failed surgery or an amputation. The federal disability rules list examples of acceptable reasons in 20 CFR 404.1530. These include a surgery that was already done without success and is now being recommended again for the same problem. They also include treatment that involves amputation. SSA also considers your physical, mental, educational and language limitations when it looks at why you didn’t follow a treatment.
- Religion or conflicting medical advice. Social Security’s ruling on failure to follow prescribed treatment (SSR 18-3p) gives more examples of good cause. These include treatment that conflicts with your religious teachings and disagreement among your own medical sources about whether you should have the treatment.
Steps to protect your claim
- Tell your doctor why. Explain your reasons plainly, whether they are fear of a repeat surgery, side effects, faith or cost. Ask your doctor to write them in your chart. A note made at the time is usually stronger than an explanation you give months later.
- Ask what else is available. Ask whether a different medication, therapy or approach could work for you. If another doctor disagrees with the recommended treatment, ask that doctor to put that opinion in writing too.
- Keep your own record. Write down the date, what treatment was offered, who offered it and why you said no. Keep copies of letters, bills and anything else that supports your reason.
Federal workers: answer within 14 days
If you are a federal employee and missed an exam that the Office of Workers’ Compensation Programs (OWCP) directed, the FECA rule on missed or obstructed exams gives you 14 days to explain in writing. Send your explanation within that window. Include any proof of your reason, such as a medical note or a record of a scheduling conflict. Keep a copy and note the date you sent it.
If you aren’t sure whether your reason is likely to count, Legal Lawsuit can help you understand your options before you respond.
When a refusal is about the care itself
Sometimes people stop treatment because they believe the care was hurting them. If that is your situation, it helps to separate two questions. The first is whether you could say no. The second is whether a provider’s care harmed you.
Refusing care and being harmed by care are different issues
Refusing treatment is a decision you make about your own body. Hospitals that take part in Medicare must respect a patient’s right to make informed decisions and to request or refuse treatment. That right lets you decline care. It does not let you demand treatment that is not medically necessary.
Being harmed by negligent care is a different matter. It is about whether a provider’s treatment caused you an injury. A claim like that has its own rules and its own proof, separate from your original injury claim, your SSDI case, or your workers’ comp file.
What you can do now
- Write down what happened. Note the treatment, when it started, the symptoms or reactions you had, and when and why you stopped.
- Keep your records. Save visit notes, prescriptions, test results, and any messages with your providers.
- Ask another doctor. A second medical opinion can help you understand whether the treatment fit your condition. It can also give you a safer care plan going forward.
- Learn about the separate claim. If you think a provider’s treatment caused your injury, our guide to filing a medical malpractice claim explains how that process works.
If you are not sure which situation you are in, Legal Lawsuit can help you understand your options and connect you with help. Legal Lawsuit is not a law firm, does not give legal advice, and cannot promise any result. It is a place to start sorting out your next step at a pace that works for you.
Frequently asked questions
Can a hospital make me accept treatment I don’t want?
Generally, no. Hospitals that take part in Medicare must protect patient rights, including your right to make informed decisions and to request or refuse treatment. The same rule works in the other direction too: this right does not let you demand treatment that is medically unnecessary. If you decline care, ask the staff to note your decision and your reasons in your chart.
Will Social Security deny my claim if I can’t afford my prescribed treatment?
Not if cost is the real barrier. Social Security’s ruling on this issue treats being unable to afford prescribed treatment as a possible good cause, as long as you are willing to accept the treatment and no free community resources are available to you. The ruling also places the burden of showing good cause on you, so keep proof of what you were charged and any clinics or programs you contacted.
What happens if I miss a medical exam in a federal workers’ comp claim?
Under the federal employees’ compensation program (FECA), refusing or obstructing an exam that OWCP directs suspends your compensation. Benefits for the period of refusal are forfeited and treated as an overpayment. You get 14 days to explain why you didn’t attend, and payments resume from the date you agree to go.
If something kept you from attending, such as illness, a transportation problem or a scheduling conflict, respond within those 14 days and include whatever records back up your explanation.
Does refusing surgery automatically ruin a personal injury case?
No. In California, for example, the jury instruction on this issue says the defendant has to prove which damages you could have avoided with reasonable effort or expense. Only that avoidable part is barred, not your whole claim. Rules differ from state to state, so if you are weighing a surgery decision while your case is open, a lawyer licensed where you live can explain how your state handles it.
What if two of my doctors disagree about the treatment I should have?
For Social Security, it can count in your favor. Without a good reason, not following prescribed treatment can lead SSA to deny or stop benefits. However, the same SSA ruling on prescribed treatment lists disagreement among your own medical sources as one example of good cause. Ask each doctor to put their recommendation in writing so the conflict is clearly documented in your file.
Sources
- 20 CFR 404.1530 – Need to follow prescribed treatment · Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR)
- SSR 18-3p: Titles II and XVI: Failure to Follow Prescribed Treatment · Social Security Administration · 2018-10-02
- CACI No. 3930. Mitigation of Damages (Personal Injury) · Judicial Council of California Civil Jury Instructions (via Justia)
- 20 CFR 10.323 – Penalties for failing to report for or obstructing a second opinion or referee examination · Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR), U.S. Department of Labor
This article is general information, not legal advice. Laws and deadlines vary by state and change over time; check the linked sources or speak with a licensed attorney about your situation.
Related Posts
Ninguna calculadora en línea sabe cuánto recibirás de un acuerdo por filtración de datos. Esta guía explica cómo se reparte realmente el dinero y cómo calcular tus propias pérdidas documentadas antes de presentar tu reclamo.
Learn about burns, dental trauma, and other documented vaping explosion injuries, then organize product details and treatment records for reporting and a claim discussion.
MRS BPO, LLC is a debt collection and accounts receivable firm based in Cherry Hill, New Jersey. This guide covers what its letter has to tell you, how to dispute the debt in writing, and how to control contact while you check it.




